Slice to Meet You: Hamilton’s Best Pizzas to Satisfy Any Craving!
Hamiltonians know pizza. From thick, cheesy deep-dish to thin-crust perfection, our city has a lineup of places that are flipping pies worthy of any pizza lover’s dream. After rigorous “testing” (tough job, right?), we’ve narrowed down the best spots in the city that are slinging slices that’ll make you say, "Wow, that’s a slice!" Here are the absolute best pizzas Hamilton has to offer.
Cowabunga
📍 Addresses: 536 Upper Wellington St (Takeout Only) and 30 Vine St (Eat-In)
☎️ Phone: (905) 575-1717
Cowabunga made waves—and headlines—when it won the title of "World’s Best Cheese Slice" at the 2024 International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas. Yep, Hamilton’s very own Cowabunga took on the world and came out on top! Known for its classic New York-style pizza, Cowabunga’s cheese slice is that perfect balance of a thin, slightly chewy crust, gooey cheese, and a sauce that hits all the right notes. The Vine Street location offers a cozy eat-in experience, while the Upper Wellington spot is ideal for quick takeout on those busy Hamilton days. This place has truly put Hamilton on the international pizza map!
Tony G’s Pizzeria
📍 Address: 30 John St N, Hamilton, ON L8R 1G9
☎️ Phone: (905) 524-1010
Tony G's has become a beloved fixture in the downtown area with its tried-and-true New York-style pies. With a foldable, thin crust, tangy tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese, Tony G’s offers the quintessential pizza experience that feels both nostalgic and timeless. If you’re a purist at heart, Tony G’s is the spot to hit.
Maipai
📍 Address: 631 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 3A1
☎️ Phone: (905) 581-9030
Maipai is the king of Detroit-style pizza in Hamilton. This style, known for its thick, pillowy crust, crispy edges, and a caramelized cheese layer, makes each slice a textural wonder. Maipai brings a modern twist to this style, pairing the doughy goodness with a fresh and inventive array of toppings. It’s a unique pizza experience that Hamiltonians love, and it stands out for being both satisfying and totally different from the traditional thin-crust options.
Shorty's Pizza
📍 Address: 1099 Cannon St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 2J6
☎️ Phone: (905) 312-9293
Shorty’s brings back the charm of the classic neighborhood pizzeria with its retro vibes and dedication to simple, delicious pizza. Their New York-style pies are perfect for folding and digging into, loaded with just enough cheese and a slightly sweet, tangy sauce that doesn’t overpower. It’s the kind of pizza that feels like it came straight out of a ‘90s movie scene, making it a beloved spot on Cannon Street.
Chicago Style Pizza
📍 Address: 534 Upper Sherman Ave, Hamilton, ON L8V 3M1
☎️ Phone: (905) 575-8800
If you’re craving deep-dish goodness, Chicago Style Pizza has you covered. Their authentic Chicago-style pizza is an experience: buttery, thick crust, piles of cheese, and a savory tomato sauce that layers on top. It’s hearty, indulgent, and pure comfort in pizza form. Upper Sherman is where to go if you want that true taste of Chicago without leaving Hamilton.
Mario's Pizza and Wings
📍 Address: 171 Mohawk Rd E, Hamilton, ON L9A 2H4
☎️ Phone: (905) 383-7777
For Hamiltonians on a budget, Mario’s is a gem. With some of the most affordable prices around, Mario’s offers quality pizza without breaking the bank. Perfect for family gatherings or late-night cravings, this place has a down-to-earth vibe and flavors that keep customers coming back. And if you’re in the mood for wings, Mario’s has those on point too!
Flora Pizzeria
📍 Address: 4 Young St, Hamilton, ON L8N 1T9
☎️ Phone: (365) 324-4599
Flora Pizzeria is all about quality, artisanal Roman-style pizza. The rectangular pies feature a thin, crunchy crust that’s all about balancing flavor and simplicity. Each slice is crafted with high-quality ingredients, and their focus on fresh, local produce makes the flavors shine. Perfect for a gourmet pizza night, Flora’s pizzas are sophisticated, yet still capture the essence of a good, honest slice.
Honourable Mentions: More Great Pizza Spots in Hamilton
While the above are the cream of the crop, Hamilton has even more places where you can grab a great slice or pie. Here are some honorable mentions that deserve a shoutout:
Alfredo's Place
📍 931 Fennell Ave E, Hamilton, ON L8V 1W9Bronzie's Place
📍 201 James St S, Hamilton, ON L8P 3A8Castelli Mercato
📍 13 Hatton Dr, Ancaster, ON L9G 2H5Garth Pizza & Wings
📍 1300 Garth St, Hamilton, ON L9C 0E1Greenhill Pizza and Wings
📍 399 Greenhill Ave, Hamilton, ON L8K 6N5Hi-Line Pizza & Wings
📍 1150 King St E, Hamilton, ON L8M 1E8National Pizza & Wings
📍 870 Upper James St, Hamilton, ON L9C 7N1
In a Pizza Slice, Hamilton's Got It All!
From award-winning cheese slices to hearty deep-dish pies, Hamilton’s pizza scene is thriving and packed with flavor. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, thick crust, or something in between, these local pizzerias have something for everyone. So grab a friend, grab a slice, and enjoy all the pizza magic Hamilton has to offer.
